> Any thoughts?

I got an idea of how to solve this problem in an OS-independent manner. The USB
devices and hubs form a tree, like this

  Root  HUB
  0   1   2
  |   |   \__...
  |   \___
 DevY     \
         HUB
        0 1 2
        |   |
        |  DevX
       HUB
      0 1 2
          |
        DevZ

This tree can be considered as an ordered tree, if you read it from left to right.
In that order, the devices are orderd

DevY - DevZ - DevX

Since the devices are ordered, the "instance" parameter from musb_init can be used
to identify them uniquely, like

instance==0   => DevY
instance==1   => DevZ
instance==2   => DevX

So I would say that we can use the current API using the "instance" parameter to
uniquely access a device. All we have to do is to build that tree, sort it, and then
use the instance parameter as an entry to that tree. The sorting takes care of
different ordering, which can happen during enumeration (depeding on power-up
sequence, phase of the Moon etc.). So if you have three devices like above, DevZ
should alway be at "instance==1". The only problem is if you unplug DevY for
example, then you get the map

instance==0   => DevZ
instance==1   => DevX

which is different from above. But if you have a different number of devices, you
likely have to change your frontend cody anyhow, so you can change the device
mapping there as well. 

In order to simplify the code, I would not build a complete tree and sort it, but
scan the whole tree hierarchically, i.e. look at

Bus1/Port1
Bus1/Port2
Bus1/...
Bus2/Port1
Bus2/Port2
...

Since there is a maximum of toal 127 USB devices, this scan should be pretty quick.
If you find a device with matching vendor and product ID, you increment an internal
counter. If that counter matches your instance parameter, you open that device.

The ultimate solution of course is to put an additional address into each device, so
you can distinguish them easily. For a out-of-the box Web cam you probably have no
chance, but for the home-made MSCB nodes I put such an address into each node, so I
can distinguish them even if the have the same product and vendor ID.

> root -l
root> TFile *f = new TFile("run00064.root")
root> TTree *t = f->Get("Trigger")
root> t->StartViewer() // look at the ROOT TTree
root> t->MakeSelector() // generates Trigger.h, Trigger.C

edit run.C, the main program:
{
gROOT->Reset();
TFile f("data/run00064.root");
TTree *t = f.Get("Trigger");

TH1D* adc8 = new TH1D("adc8","ADC8",1500,0,1500-1);
TH1D* tdc2 = new TH1D("tdc2","TDC2",1500,0,1500-1);
TH2D* h12 = new TH2D("h2","ADC8 vs TDC2",100,0,1500,100,0,1500);
TH2D* h12cut = new TH2D("h2cut","ADC8 vs TDC2",50,0,1000-1,50,0,1500);

TSelector *s = TSelector::GetSelector("Trigger.C");
t->Process(s);

adc8->Draw();
tdc2->Draw();
h12->Draw();
h12cut->Draw();
}

edit Trigger.C:

Bool_t Trigger::ProcessCut(Int_t entry)
{
  fChain->GetTree()->GetEntry(entry);
  if (entry%100 == 0) printf("entry %d\r",entry);
  return kTRUE;
}

void Trigger::ProcessFill(Int_t entry)
{
  adc8->Fill(ADCS_ADCS[8]);
  tdc2->Fill(TDCS_TDCS[2]);
  h12->Fill(TDCS_TDCS[2],ADCS_ADCS[8]);
  if (ADCS_ADCS[8] > 100)
    h12cut->Fill(TDCS_TDCS[2],ADCS_ADCS[8]);
}

Run the analysis:

root -l
root> .x run.C

K.O.

> root -l
root> TFile *f = new TFile("run00064.root")
root> TTree *t = f->Get("Trigger")
root> t->StartViewer() // look at the ROOT TTree
root> t->MakeSelector() // generates Trigger.h, Trigger.C

edit run.C, the main program:
{
gROOT->Reset();
TFile f("data/run00064.root");
TTree *t = f.Get("Trigger");

TH1D* adc8 = new TH1D("adc8","ADC8",1500,0,1500-1);
TH1D* tdc2 = new TH1D("tdc2","TDC2",1500,0,1500-1);
TH2D* h12 = new TH2D("h2","ADC8 vs TDC2",100,0,1500,100,0,1500);
TH2D* h12cut = new TH2D("h2cut","ADC8 vs TDC2",50,0,1000-1,50,0,1500);

TSelector *s = TSelector::GetSelector("Trigger.C");
t->Process(s);

adc8->Draw();
tdc2->Draw();
h12->Draw();
h12cut->Draw();
}

edit Trigger.C:

Bool_t Trigger::ProcessCut(Int_t entry)
{
  fChain->GetTree()->GetEntry(entry);
  if (entry%100 == 0) printf("entry %d\r",entry);
  return kTRUE;
}

void Trigger::ProcessFill(Int_t entry)
{
  adc8->Fill(ADCS_ADCS[8]);
  tdc2->Fill(TDCS_TDCS[2]);
  h12->Fill(TDCS_TDCS[2],ADCS_ADCS[8]);
  if (ADCS_ADCS[8] > 100)
    h12cut->Fill(TDCS_TDCS[2],ADCS_ADCS[8]);
}

Run the analysis:

root -l
root> .x run.C

K.O.

> root -l
root> TFile *f = new TFile("run00064.root")
root> TTree *t = f->Get("Trigger")
root> t->StartViewer() // look at the ROOT TTree
root> t->MakeSelector() // generates Trigger.h, Trigger.C

edit run.C, the main program:
{
gROOT->Reset();
TFile f("data/run00064.root");
TTree *t = f.Get("Trigger");

TH1D* adc8 = new TH1D("adc8","ADC8",1500,0,1500-1);
TH1D* tdc2 = new TH1D("tdc2","TDC2",1500,0,1500-1);
TH2D* h12 = new TH2D("h2","ADC8 vs TDC2",100,0,1500,100,0,1500);
TH2D* h12cut = new TH2D("h2cut","ADC8 vs TDC2",50,0,1000-1,50,0,1500);

TSelector *s = TSelector::GetSelector("Trigger.C");
t->Process(s);

adc8->Draw();
tdc2->Draw();
h12->Draw();
h12cut->Draw();
}

edit Trigger.C:

Bool_t Trigger::ProcessCut(Int_t entry)
{
  fChain->GetTree()->GetEntry(entry);
  if (entry%100 == 0) printf("entry %d\r",entry);
  return kTRUE;
}

void Trigger::ProcessFill(Int_t entry)
{
  adc8->Fill(ADCS_ADCS[8]);
  tdc2->Fill(TDCS_TDCS[2]);
  h12->Fill(TDCS_TDCS[2],ADCS_ADCS[8]);
  if (ADCS_ADCS[8] > 100)
    h12cut->Fill(TDCS_TDCS[2],ADCS_ADCS[8]);
}

Run the analysis:

root -l
root> .x run.C

K.O.

Updating the instructions to ROOT version 3.10.2. Example is from TRIUMF-KOPIO
tree analysis.

shell> root -l
root> TFile *f = new TFile("run00064.root")
root> Trigger->MakeSelector("TriggerSelector")  // "Trigger" is the tree name
inside the root file. Generates TriggerSelector.h and TriggerSelector.cpp

= edit run.C, the main program:

{
gROOT->Reset();
TSelector *s = TSelector::GetSelector("TriggerSelector.C");

TChain chain("Trigger"); // "Trigger" is the tree name inside the root files
chain.Add("run03016.root"); // can chain multiple files

TH1D* tdc2 = new TH1D("tdc2","TDC2",1500,0,1500-1);

chain.Process(s,"",500); // process 500 events
//chain.Process(s); // or process all events

tdc2->Draw();
}

= edit TriggerSelector.h:

in the TriggerSelector class members, i.e. "UInt_t TDC1_TDC1[47];" edit the
array size to be bigger than the maximum possible bank size

= edit TriggerSelector.C:

Bool_t TriggerSelector::Process(Int_t entry)
{
  fChain->GetTree()->GetEntry(entry);

  if (entry%100 == 0)
    printf("process %d, nTDC %3d, 0x%08x\n",entry,TDC1_nTDC1,TDC1_TDC1[1]);

  tdc2->Fill(TDC1_nTDC1);
  return kTRUE;
}

= Run the analysis:

shell> root -l
root> .x run.C
 
K.O.

Updating the instructions to ROOT version 3.10.2. Example is from TRIUMF-KOPIO
tree analysis.

shell> root -l
root> TFile *f = new TFile("run00064.root")
root> Trigger->MakeSelector("TriggerSelector")  // "Trigger" is the tree name
inside the root file. Generates TriggerSelector.h and TriggerSelector.cpp

= edit run.C, the main program:

{
gROOT->Reset();
TSelector *s = TSelector::GetSelector("TriggerSelector.C");

TChain chain("Trigger"); // "Trigger" is the tree name inside the root files
chain.Add("run03016.root"); // can chain multiple files

TH1D* tdc2 = new TH1D("tdc2","TDC2",1500,0,1500-1);

chain.Process(s,"",500); // process 500 events
//chain.Process(s); // or process all events

tdc2->Draw();
}

= edit TriggerSelector.h:

in the TriggerSelector class members, i.e. "UInt_t TDC1_TDC1[47];" edit the
array size to be bigger than the maximum possible bank size

= edit TriggerSelector.C:

Bool_t TriggerSelector::Process(Int_t entry)
{
  fChain->GetTree()->GetEntry(entry);

  if (entry%100 == 0)
    printf("process %d, nTDC %3d, 0x%08x\n",entry,TDC1_nTDC1,TDC1_TDC1[1]);

  tdc2->Fill(TDC1_nTDC1);
  return kTRUE;
}

= Run the analysis:

shell> root -l
root> .x run.C
 
K.O.

Updating the instructions to ROOT version 3.10.2. Example is from TRIUMF-KOPIO
tree analysis.

shell> root -l
root> TFile *f = new TFile("run00064.root")
root> Trigger->MakeSelector("TriggerSelector")  // "Trigger" is the tree name
inside the root file. Generates TriggerSelector.h and TriggerSelector.cpp

= edit run.C, the main program:

{
gROOT->Reset();
TSelector *s = TSelector::GetSelector("TriggerSelector.C");

TChain chain("Trigger"); // "Trigger" is the tree name inside the root files
chain.Add("run03016.root"); // can chain multiple files

TH1D* tdc2 = new TH1D("tdc2","TDC2",1500,0,1500-1);

chain.Process(s,"",500); // process 500 events
//chain.Process(s); // or process all events

tdc2->Draw();
}

= edit TriggerSelector.h:

in the TriggerSelector class members, i.e. "UInt_t TDC1_TDC1[47];" edit the
array size to be bigger than the maximum possible bank size

= edit TriggerSelector.C:

Bool_t TriggerSelector::Process(Int_t entry)
{
  fChain->GetTree()->GetEntry(entry);

  if (entry%100 == 0)
    printf("process %d, nTDC %3d, 0x%08x\n",entry,TDC1_nTDC1,TDC1_TDC1[1]);

  tdc2->Fill(TDC1_nTDC1);
  return kTRUE;
}

= Run the analysis:

shell> root -l
root> .x run.C
 
K.O.

With recent changes to mana.c, creation of user ROOT objects in the MIDAS
analyser has changed. Here is the new example code for creating ROOT objects
that are visible in ROODY and are saved into the histogram file.

1) in the "global" context (outside of any function)

#include <TH1D.h>
#include <TProfile.h>

static TH1D* gMyHist1 = 0;
static TProfile* gMyHist2 = 0;

2) In the analyzer "init" or "begin run" method, create the histogram:

//extern TFolder *gManaHistosFolder; // from midas.h
gMyHist1 = new TH1D("gMyHist1",...);
gMyHist2 = new TProfile("gMyHist2",...);
gManaHistosFolder->Add(gMyHist1);
gManaHistosFolder->Add(gMyHist2);

(note: this will produce an warning about "possible memory leak")

3) In the per-event method, fill the histograms

gMyHist1->Fill(x);
gMyHist2->Fill(x,y);

4) In the Makefile, where you compile the frontend, add "-DUSE_ROOT" right after
"-I$(ROOTSYS)/include"

K.O.

> (preliminary, untested. I will keep this updated as I get testing feedback)
> 
> With recent changes to mana.c, creation of user ROOT objects in the MIDAS
> analyser has changed. Here is the new example code for creating ROOT objects
> that are visible in ROODY and are saved into the histogram file.
> 
> 1) in the "global" context (outside of any function)
> 
> #include <TH1D.h>
> #include <TProfile.h>
> 
> static TH1D* gMyHist1 = 0;
> static TProfile* gMyHist2 = 0;
> 
> 2) In the analyzer "init" or "begin run" method, create the histogram:
> 
> //extern TFolder *gManaHistosFolder; // from midas.h
> gMyHist1 = new TH1D("gMyHist1",...);
> gMyHist2 = new TProfile("gMyHist2",...);
> gManaHistosFolder->Add(gMyHist1);
> gManaHistosFolder->Add(gMyHist2);
> 
> (note: this will produce an warning about "possible memory leak")
> 
> 3) In the per-event method, fill the histograms
> 
> gMyHist1->Fill(x);
> gMyHist2->Fill(x,y);
> 
> K.O.


the book functions provide a convenient place to check against object duplication
and memory leaks etc., and a place to ensure that consistent subfolders are being
used.  eg. a while back we decided that TCutGs should be in a "cuts" subfolder.

To extend the booking to TProfile is fairly easy.  In fact if you want to
use the simple constructor TProfile::TProfile (const char *, const char *, Int_t,
Axis_t, Axis_t), then you could infact just use h1_book<TProfile>.

It now seems to me that the names h1_book, h2_book, cut_book are all too long
and even more upsetting are inconsistent.  Some of them are templates (most) and
some are not.  Perhaps they should all be templates, and all have the same name.
The attached patch accomplishes this (without deleting the old names).  With this
patch you can now do

gMyHist1 = book<TProfile>( "gMyHist2",...);

New book templates are needed when you (1) wish to change the subfolder, or (2)
need to use a different argument list in the constructor.  If you need help with
this for the TProfile constructors which are different from TH1D constructors then
let me know.  They should be easy to do.

For TGraph at lot depends on how you want to initialise the data points.

Before the days of javascript and ajax and web 2.0, MIDAS introduced "custom pages" for
building graphical display that could show "live" data from MIDAS and that could
have buttons and controls to operate slow controls equipment, etc.

This is how it works:
- entries from ODB /Custom are shown on the MIDAS menu -
an odb entry /Custom/Foo generate a link labeled "Foo"
to a special mhttpd url /CS/Foo.
- access to mhttpd url /CS/Foo invokes show_custom_page()
- show_custom_page() reads the custom page file name from ODB /Custom/Foo
- content of this file is served the web browser (after substituting the <odb> tags with values from ODB).
- in addition, it is possible to store the contents of the custom page in the ODB variable /Custom/Foo itself,
making it easy to edit the custom pages through the web browser (using the mhttpd odb editor).
- (if the value of /Custom/Foo has no "\n", then it's a file name, otherwise it is the page contents).
- if /Custom/Path exists, it is prepended to all file names.
- read more about this here:
https://midas.triumf.ca/MidasWiki/index.php//Custom_ODB_tree
https://midas.triumf.ca/MidasWiki/index.php/Internal_Custom_Page

This method required each custom web page served by mhttpd to have a corresponding
entry in ODB /Custom. Quite tedious for big experiments with a large number
of web pages (in T2K/ND280/FGD, for 1 page per frontend board, these entries
had to be created using a script, no practical to create them manually).

To fix this, in 2015, a modification was made to the code for ODB /Custom/Path. Instead of reading the file name
from ODB /Custom/Foo, the filename was made by adding /Custom/Path and the URL itself:
URL /CS/Foo.html will serve the file ODBValue["/Custom/Path"]/Foo.html. In this scheme,
the ODB entry /Custom/Foo.html is optional and is only needed to create a link in the MIDAS menu.

Commit: https://bitbucket.org/tmidas/midas/commits/5a2ef7d66df353684c4b40882a391b64a068f61f made on 2015-03-19.
Corresponding midas forum entry: https://midas.triumf.ca/elog/Midas/1109 made on 2015-09-09.

This change had the effect of creating 2 different operating modes for custom pages:
- if ODB /Custom/Path was absent (the default case), file names are taken from ODB /Custom/Foo.
- if ODB /Custom/Path is present (it has be created manually), file names are taken from the URLs.

These two modes could not be mixed, some experiments (TRIUMF MUSR/BNMR, CERN ALPHA, etc)
continued to use the old scheme (no /Custom/Path), some experiments switched
to the new scheme (DEAP, etc - TBC?).

(The best I can tell, this also create a security problem were using URLs containing "..", one can
force mhttpd to escape the /Custom/Path filename jail to cause it to serve arbitrary files from
the filesystem. Note that many web browsers remove the ".." entries from URLs, special tricks
are required to exploit this).

Then, in 2017, something called "new custom pages" was added to mhttpd interprete().
commit https://bitbucket.org/tmidas/midas/commits/c574a45c6da1290430f5a85a348fb629596a0de0 made on 2017-07-24
(I cannot find the corresponding explanation on the midas forum).

The best I can tell this code is intended to do the same thing that was done before:
map URLs like http://localhost:8080/Foo.html to file name ODBValue["/Custom/Path"]/Foo.html
and if this file exists, serve it to the browser.

However, the code has a bug - there is no check for absence of ODB /Custom/Path. If it does
not exist (as in experiments that do not use custom pages or use the old-style custom pages without
/Custom/Path), an empty string is used and URLs like http://localhost:8080/Foo.html becomes
mapped to /Foo.html (in the root of the file system, "/"!!!).

This introduced 3 problems:
- http://localhost:8080/etc/hosts serve the system password file (a security problem)
- because this code is before the odb code, it intercepts (and breaks) valid ODB URLs:
- on Linux, the ODB editor URL http://localhost:8080/root instead of showing the ODB root, attempts to serve the local subdirectory "/root" as a file
(fails, /root is a directory on most Linuxes). This is reported here: https://midas.triumf.ca/elog/Midas/1335 (2018-01-10)
- on MacOS, ODB editor URL http://localhost:8080/System instead of showing ODB /System, attempts to serve the local directory "/System" is a file (fails, 
/System is a subdirectory in MacOS). This is reported here: https://bitbucket.org/tmidas/midas/issues/156/mhttpd-odb-editor-cannot-open-system-on 
(2018-12-20)

The problem with broken access to the ODB editor URLs is fixed by commit:
https://bitbucket.org/tmidas/midas/commits/f071bc1daa4dc7ec582586659dd2339f1cd1fa21 (2018-12-21)
https://midas.triumf.ca/elog/Midas/1416

The fix unconditionally creates /Custom/Path and sets it to the value of $MIDAS_DIR or $MIDASSYS.

This breaks experiments that use custom pages with no /Custom/Path (ALPHA, BNMR/BNQR), see
https://bitbucket.org/tmidas/midas/issues/157/odb-custom-is-broken, and this is impossible
to fix by deleting /Custom/Path as it will be created again.

Also the problem with serving the system password file remains, see
https://midas.triumf.ca/elog/Midas/1425

So, a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SNAFU

Since then, we have changed the mhttpd URL scheme: we no longer use URL subdirectories to navigate the ODB editor (we now use &odb_path=xxx)
and to refer to custom files (use now use &cmd=custom&page=xxx).

This liberates the mhttpd URL space for serving custom files without colliding with mhttpd internals and allows us to repair the current situation.

I will propose a solution in a follow-up message.

K.O.

P.S. The actual series of malfunctions is a bit more complicated than I described in this message,
but there is no need for getting to the very bottom bottom bottom of this as we can now do
a fairly clean solution.

Parsing all URL in mhttpd to prevent /etc/passwd etc. to be returned is tricky, because people can use escape sequences etc. Therefore I think it is much better to restrict file access 
on the file system level when opening a file. The only escape there one could have is "..", which can be tested easily. 

Therefore, I propose to restrict file access to two well-defined directories, which is one system directory and one user directory. The system directory should be defined via 
$MIDASSYS/resources, and the user directory should be the experiment directory (as defined in exptab) followed by "resources". So if MIDASSYS equals to /usr/local/midas and the 
experiment directory equals to /home/users/exp for example, we would only have these two directories (and of course the subdirectories within these) served by mhttpd:

$MIDASSYS/resource -> /usr/local/midas/resources
<exptab>/resources -> /home/users/exp/resources

These directories should be hard-wired into mhttpd, and not go through and ODB entry, since otherwise one could manipulate the ODB entries (knowingly or unknowingly) and open a 
back-door. 

If users need a more complex structure, they can put soft links into these directories.

The code which opens a resource file should then first evaluate $MIDASSYS, then add "/resources/", then add the requested file name, make sure that there is no ".." in the file name, 
then open the file. If not existing, do the same for the <exptab>/resources/ directory.

This change will break most experiments, and forces people to move their custom pages to different directories, but I think it's the only clean solution and we just have to bite the 
bullet.

Comments are welcome.

Stefan

Hi Stefan and Konstantin,

I think that this proposal sounds fairly reasonable.  I agree that we might as well move to a secure final solution at this point.  

One comment: since this change would break almost every experiment I have worked on for the last 4 years, it would be nice to add a command-line option to mhttpd that preserves the old /Custom/Path behavior.  This would allow experiments a transition 
period, so that they didn't immediately need to fix their setup.  The command-line option could be clearly marked as obsolete behaviour and could be removed within a year.

Cheers,
Thomas



> Parsing all URL in mhttpd to prevent /etc/passwd etc. to be returned is tricky, because people can use escape sequences etc. Therefore I think it is much better to restrict file access 
> on the file system level when opening a file. The only escape there one could have is "..", which can be tested easily. 
> 
> Therefore, I propose to restrict file access to two well-defined directories, which is one system directory and one user directory. The system directory should be defined via 
> $MIDASSYS/resources, and the user directory should be the experiment directory (as defined in exptab) followed by "resources". So if MIDASSYS equals to /usr/local/midas and the 
> experiment directory equals to /home/users/exp for example, we would only have these two directories (and of course the subdirectories within these) served by mhttpd:
> 
> $MIDASSYS/resource -> /usr/local/midas/resources
> <exptab>/resources -> /home/users/exp/resources
> 
> These directories should be hard-wired into mhttpd, and not go through and ODB entry, since otherwise one could manipulate the ODB entries (knowingly or unknowingly) and open a 
> back-door. 
> 
> If users need a more complex structure, they can put soft links into these directories.
> 
> The code which opens a resource file should then first evaluate $MIDASSYS, then add "/resources/", then add the requested file name, make sure that there is no ".." in the file name, 
> then open the file. If not existing, do the same for the <exptab>/resources/ directory.
> 
> This change will break most experiments, and forces people to move their custom pages to different directories, but I think it's the only clean solution and we just have to bite the 
> bullet.
> 
> Comments are welcome.
> 
> Stefan

Sounds reasonable to me.

Stefan

> Hi Stefan and Konstantin,
> 
> I think that this proposal sounds fairly reasonable.  I agree that we might as well move to a secure final solution at this point.  
> 
> One comment: since this change would break almost every experiment I have worked on for the last 4 years, it would be nice to add a command-line option to mhttpd that preserves the old /Custom/Path behavior.  This would allow experiments a transition 
> period, so that they didn't immediately need to fix their setup.  The command-line option could be clearly marked as obsolete behaviour and could be removed within a year.
> 
> Cheers,
> Thomas
> 
> 
> 
> > Parsing all URL in mhttpd to prevent /etc/passwd etc. to be returned is tricky, because people can use escape sequences etc. Therefore I think it is much better to restrict file access 
> > on the file system level when opening a file. The only escape there one could have is "..", which can be tested easily. 
> > 
> > Therefore, I propose to restrict file access to two well-defined directories, which is one system directory and one user directory. The system directory should be defined via 
> > $MIDASSYS/resources, and the user directory should be the experiment directory (as defined in exptab) followed by "resources". So if MIDASSYS equals to /usr/local/midas and the 
> > experiment directory equals to /home/users/exp for example, we would only have these two directories (and of course the subdirectories within these) served by mhttpd:
> > 
> > $MIDASSYS/resource -> /usr/local/midas/resources
> > <exptab>/resources -> /home/users/exp/resources
> > 
> > These directories should be hard-wired into mhttpd, and not go through and ODB entry, since otherwise one could manipulate the ODB entries (knowingly or unknowingly) and open a 
> > back-door. 
> > 
> > If users need a more complex structure, they can put soft links into these directories.
> > 
> > The code which opens a resource file should then first evaluate $MIDASSYS, then add "/resources/", then add the requested file name, make sure that there is no ".." in the file name, 
> > then open the file. If not existing, do the same for the <exptab>/resources/ directory.
> > 
> > This change will break most experiments, and forces people to move their custom pages to different directories, but I think it's the only clean solution and we just have to bite the 
> > bullet.
> > 
> > Comments are welcome.
> > 
> > Stefan

I see two separate issues here. 

One is restricting the custom pages to ONE directory such as 
<exptab>/resources -> /home/users/exp/resources
and its subdirectories which seems like a good solution for all the
reasons you've mentioned. 

The other issue is the use of the "Path" key in /Custom, which is used to differentiate
between the "new" way (all resources served from the Path directory) 
and the original way where all the custom keys are specified with their full directories.

Recent versions of Midas had broken the original behaviour by insisting on the presence of the
"Path" key.  Konstantin fixed this by allowing the "Path" key to take the value "".  It is true
that some experiments currently may be serving resources from more than one directory tree, but changing
to storage of all custom pages in one directory (and its subdirectories) does not necessarily mean that
the original way of serving resources must be made obsolete.
 
I actually like the original way of specifying the custom keys for the pages and resources under /Custom, which
is presently selected  without the /Custom/Path key present at all (older versions) or with the
/Custom/Path key set to "" (latest versions). I like it for debugging, and I like to be able to see 
at a glance what resource files are in use from /Custom. 

I have a suggestion:

The resources could still be served from the /Custom directory if desired, except now mhttpd will ALWAYS add the 
fixed path in front of the given paths in /Custom. This would mean a fixed path and a minimal disruption to older pages 
(the <script> and <link> statements in the HTML code to include the resources would not need to be changed).
The "/Path" key is no longer be useful, since the resource path is now fixed. Instead a key e.g. "FlagRS"  could 
be used to select the desired behaviour,  with the default being the "new" (no key present).

For example, the full directory paths in /custom
ScanParams&                     /home/users/online/custom/scan/scan_select_popup.html
mpet.css!                       /home/users/online/custom/rs/mpet.css
scanvoltages!                   /home/users/online/custom/scan/scan_voltages.js

would become subdirectory path(s)
ScanParams&                     custom/scan/scan_select_popup.html
mpet.css!                       custom/rs/mpet.css
scanvoltages!                   custom/scan/scan_voltages.js
FlagRS                          y

The pages would be served from /home/users/exp/resources/custom/...

Suzannah

 
> > Hi Stefan and Konstantin,
> > 
> > I think that this proposal sounds fairly reasonable.  I agree that we might as well move to a secure final solution at this point.  
> > 
> > One comment: since this change would break almost every experiment I have worked on for the last 4 years, it would be nice to add a command-line option to mhttpd that preserves the old /Custom/Path behavior.  This would allow experiments a transition 
> > period, so that they didn't immediately need to fix their setup.  The command-line option could be clearly marked as obsolete behaviour and could be removed within a year.
> > 
> > Cheers,
> > Thomas
> > 
> > 
> > 
> > > Parsing all URL in mhttpd to prevent /etc/passwd etc. to be returned is tricky, because people can use escape sequences etc. Therefore I think it is much better to restrict file access 
> > > on the file system level when opening a file. The only escape there one could have is "..", which can be tested easily. 
> > > 
> > > Therefore, I propose to restrict file access to two well-defined directories, which is one system directory and one user directory. The system directory should be defined via 
> > > $MIDASSYS/resources, and the user directory should be the experiment directory (as defined in exptab) followed by "resources". So if MIDASSYS equals to /usr/local/midas and the 
> > > experiment directory equals to /home/users/exp for example, we would only have these two directories (and of course the subdirectories within these) served by mhttpd:
> > > 
> > > $MIDASSYS/resource -> /usr/local/midas/resources
> > > <exptab>/resources -> /home/users/exp/resources
> > > 
> > > These directories should be hard-wired into mhttpd, and not go through and ODB entry, since otherwise one could manipulate the ODB entries (knowingly or unknowingly) and open a 
> > > back-door. 
> > > 
> > > If users need a more complex structure, they can put soft links into these directories.
> > > 
> > > The code which opens a resource file should then first evaluate $MIDASSYS, then add "/resources/", then add the requested file name, make sure that there is no ".." in the file name, 
> > > then open the file. If not existing, do the same for the <exptab>/resources/ directory.
> > > 
> > > This change will break most experiments, and forces people to move their custom pages to different directories, but I think it's the only clean solution and we just have to bite the 
> > > bullet.
> > > 
> > > Comments are welcome.
> > > 
> > > Stefan

Hi, guys, as I was exploring the code and the commit history on Thursday (git rules!) and
as I worked on getting the old custom files to work with Suzannah on Friday, I think
I know how I want this code to work. I think there is no need to break with the old
way of doing things and force every experiment to move things around if they want
to use the latest midas.

I will write more about this, but in the nutshell, I am happy with the current code:
- the old custom pages work (filename is taken from ODB, with /Custom/Path prepended if it exists; this is what we had for a very long time)
- the serving of new custom pages also works - via Stefan's code in interprete() where /Custom/File is added to the URL
  and if the file exists, we serve it. The only problem in that code was the missing check for absent or empty ODB /Custom/Path.
- the serving of new custom pages through the normal resource path (show_resource()) also works now,
   this serves files from $MIDASSYS/resource, from ODB /Experiment/Resource and a few other locations. (this code was there
   for a long time, but disabled because for a number of reasons, things like http://localhost:8080/Status.html did not work right,
   and after fixing a few buglets, they do now).

The serving of /etc/passwd I killed by forbidding "/" (the directory separator) in resource file names. I think this is safer
for enforcing a file jail compared to checking for "..".

I think the current code fixes all the reported problems (in conjunction with the change of the URL scheme) -
- /Custom/Path set to "" now works and provides the old way of doing custom pages
- /Custom/Path set to a directory name works and all Thomas's experiments should be good. the old custom files way *also* works, as long as the filenames in ODB are adjusted.
- URL /root and /System no longer try to serve system directories, plus /Custom/Path set to "/" is explicitly forbidden.
- mhttpd cannot serve /etc/passwd by default as "/" is forbidden in file names added to /Custom/Path. (I discount the case where mhttpd is running in /etc or /Custom/Path is set to /etc or symlinked to /etc)

But not all is good. The change of custom page URL scheme from /CS/... to top level or ?cmd=custom&page=...
cannot be swept under the rug - the user will have to make changes to their custom pages to adjust for it,
I see no way to avoid that. The current code catches and redirects/serves/helps with some of that,
i.e. pages loading custom files like "bnmr.css" still work even though bnmr.css is no longer under /CS/bnmr.css).

Again, apologies that things are moving faster than I can write them up. I am trying.


K.O.


> I see two separate issues here. 
> 
> One is restricting the custom pages to ONE directory such as 
> <exptab>/resources -> /home/users/exp/resources
> and its subdirectories which seems like a good solution for all the
> reasons you've mentioned. 
> 
> The other issue is the use of the "Path" key in /Custom, which is used to differentiate
> between the "new" way (all resources served from the Path directory) 
> and the original way where all the custom keys are specified with their full directories.
> 
> Recent versions of Midas had broken the original behaviour by insisting on the presence of the
> "Path" key.  Konstantin fixed this by allowing the "Path" key to take the value "".  It is true
> that some experiments currently may be serving resources from more than one directory tree, but changing
> to storage of all custom pages in one directory (and its subdirectories) does not necessarily mean that
> the original way of serving resources must be made obsolete.
>  
> I actually like the original way of specifying the custom keys for the pages and resources under /Custom, which
> is presently selected  without the /Custom/Path key present at all (older versions) or with the
> /Custom/Path key set to "" (latest versions). I like it for debugging, and I like to be able to see 
> at a glance what resource files are in use from /Custom. 
> 
> I have a suggestion:
> 
> The resources could still be served from the /Custom directory if desired, except now mhttpd will ALWAYS add the 
> fixed path in front of the given paths in /Custom. This would mean a fixed path and a minimal disruption to older pages 
> (the <script> and <link> statements in the HTML code to include the resources would not need to be changed).
> The "/Path" key is no longer be useful, since the resource path is now fixed. Instead a key e.g. "FlagRS"  could 
> be used to select the desired behaviour,  with the default being the "new" (no key present).
> 
> For example, the full directory paths in /custom
> ScanParams&                     /home/users/online/custom/scan/scan_select_popup.html
> mpet.css!                       /home/users/online/custom/rs/mpet.css
> scanvoltages!                   /home/users/online/custom/scan/scan_voltages.js
> 
> would become subdirectory path(s)
> ScanParams&                     custom/scan/scan_select_popup.html
> mpet.css!                       custom/rs/mpet.css
> scanvoltages!                   custom/scan/scan_voltages.js
> FlagRS                          y
> 
> The pages would be served from /home/users/exp/resources/custom/...
> 
> Suzannah
> 
>  
> > > Hi Stefan and Konstantin,
> > > 
> > > I think that this proposal sounds fairly reasonable.  I agree that we might as well move to a secure final solution at this point.  
> > > 
> > > One comment: since this change would break almost every experiment I have worked on for the last 4 years, it would be nice to add a command-line option to mhttpd that preserves the old /Custom/Path behavior.  This would allow experiments a transition 
> > > period, so that they didn't immediately need to fix their setup.  The command-line option could be clearly marked as obsolete behaviour and could be removed within a year.
> > > 
> > > Cheers,
> > > Thomas
> > > 
> > > 
> > > 
> > > > Parsing all URL in mhttpd to prevent /etc/passwd etc. to be returned is tricky, because people can use escape sequences etc. Therefore I think it is much better to restrict file access 
> > > > on the file system level when opening a file. The only escape there one could have is "..", which can be tested easily. 
> > > > 
> > > > Therefore, I propose to restrict file access to two well-defined directories, which is one system directory and one user directory. The system directory should be defined via 
> > > > $MIDASSYS/resources, and the user directory should be the experiment directory (as defined in exptab) followed by "resources". So if MIDASSYS equals to /usr/local/midas and the 
> > > > experiment directory equals to /home/users/exp for example, we would only have these two directories (and of course the subdirectories within these) served by mhttpd:
> > > > 
> > > > $MIDASSYS/resource -> /usr/local/midas/resources
> > > > <exptab>/resources -> /home/users/exp/resources
> > > > 
> > > > These directories should be hard-wired into mhttpd, and not go through and ODB entry, since otherwise one could manipulate the ODB entries (knowingly or unknowingly) and open a 
> > > > back-door. 
> > > > 
> > > > If users need a more complex structure, they can put soft links into these directories.
> > > > 
> > > > The code which opens a resource file should then first evaluate $MIDASSYS, then add "/resources/", then add the requested file name, make sure that there is no ".." in the file name, 
> > > > then open the file. If not existing, do the same for the <exptab>/resources/ directory.
> > > > 
> > > > This change will break most experiments, and forces people to move their custom pages to different directories, but I think it's the only clean solution and we just have to bite the 
> > > > bullet.
> > > > 
> > > > Comments are welcome.
> > > > 
> > > > Stefan

First, I did not propose to give up the /Custom tree in the ODB, sorry for the misunderstanding. We still need it in order to display the menu with the custom pages at the left side navigation bar. In principle all can stay like it is, except we remove /Custom/Path and rewrite the file server to restrict it only 
to the two mentioned directories.

Second, to keep the compatibility with running experiments, we have to make the move over as simply as possible. Thomas proposed a "deprecated" mhttpd command line option. As an alternative, I propose to make a symbolic link from <exptab>/resources to where the old /Custom/Path was pointing 
to. This should work as well, and we don't have to implement a parameter in mhttpd.

Third, the /Custom/Path should really go away. We are all concerned that people can read security critical files from the whole file system. To read those files, people have to access to mhttpd, so they have to know at least the authentication credentials to pass the Apache firewall in front of mhttpd or 
whatever. This means they have access to the ODB, and then they can simply change /Custom/Path to "/" and voila - they have again access to /etc/passwd. This is why I propose symbolic links on the file system. This area is much better protected than the ODB, since people have to physically log into 
a machine to change it.

Best,
Stefan

> - mhttpd cannot serve /etc/passwd by default as "/" is forbidden in file names added to /Custom/Path.

You do this with a simple

if (custom_path == "/")

which does work but does not cover cases such as

"/./"
"/etc/../"
"/home/meg/../../"

Good luck with finding all the weird combinations which can lead to break ins. So we are where we were before.

Still, in my opinion we should not have a path in the ODB. The custom path should be hard-wired and combined with symbolic links if necessary. The custom HTML pages under /Custom in the ODB have to be scanned for ".."s.

Stefan

> > - mhttpd cannot serve /etc/passwd by default as "/" is forbidden in file names added to /Custom/Path.
> You do this with a simple
> if (custom_path == "/")
> which does work but does not cover cases such as
> "/./"

Hmm... and this is just fine. Since I do not allow "/" in the file name, they can
set the resource path to any alias for the root filesystem, but they cannot
get to "/etc/passwd" unless they run mhttpd in /etc or set /Custom/Path to "/etc".

All these cases are not normal use of mhttpd, not "oops, I made a mistake"
and not "I will kludge my paths just for today just for this one experiment". They
have to make an explicit decision to break the security.

These days, I am thinking that we should not try to prevent all insecure uses of midas,
but at least we should make the default configuration secure and disallow some of the more
obviously insecure configurations (i.e. do not permit password protection without https).

Take the root password as an example. Empty root passwd is not permitted, but
root password set to "root" is allowed (some password tools may throw a warning).

>
> Still, in my opinion we should not have a path in the ODB. The custom path should be hard-wired and combined with symbolic links if necessary. The custom HTML pages under /Custom in the ODB have to be scanned for ".."s.
> 

Stefan, we already allow execution of arbitrary commands via ODB "/Programs/xxx/Start Command".

So for all practical purposes, somebody with access to the mhttpd web pages also has shell access
to the user account running mhttpd.

K.O.

> First, I did not propose to give up the /Custom tree in the ODB, sorry for the misunderstanding. We still need it in order to display the menu with the custom pages at the left side navigation bar. In principle all can stay like it is, except we remove /Custom/Path and rewrite the file server to restrict it only 
> to the two mentioned directories.
> 
> Second, to keep the compatibility with running experiments, we have to make the move over as simply as possible. Thomas proposed a "deprecated" mhttpd command line option. As an alternative, I propose to make a symbolic link from <exptab>/resources to where the old /Custom/Path was pointing 
> to. This should work as well, and we don't have to implement a parameter in mhttpd.

That sounds fine, as long as it is clearly documented.

> Third, the /Custom/Path should really go away. We are all concerned that people can read security critical files from the whole file system. To read those files, people have to access to mhttpd, so they have to know at least the authentication credentials to pass the Apache firewall in front of mhttpd or 
> whatever. This means they have access to the ODB, and then they can simply change /Custom/Path to "/" and voila - they have again access to /etc/passwd. This is why I propose symbolic links on the file system. This area is much better protected than the ODB, since people have to physically log into 
> a machine to change it.

Yes, I agree that /Custom/Path should go away.

Cheers,
Thomas

> First, I did not propose to give up the /Custom tree in the ODB, sorry for the misunderstanding.
> We still need it in order to display the menu with the custom pages at the left side navigation bar.
> In principle all can stay like it is, except we remove /Custom/Path and rewrite the file server to restrict it only 
> to the two mentioned directories.
> 

We have several large installations at TRIUMF that use the old-style custom pages - MUSR, BNMR/BNQR, TITAN (and more?) -
none of these experiments are going away any time soon and none of these custom pages are rewriting themselves.

So, I think we are stuck with supporting old-style custom pages in the short and in the long term, unless we decide to abandon these existing users of MIDAS.

And the old-style custom pages come with the old-style scheme of keeping file names in ODB. Removing
it will require experiments to reorganize their filesystems (different custom pages may come from different
git repositories on different disks - not trivially placable all in the same directory).

Plus some people (including myself) like to have some things explicitly specified - I want to know that
this page loads this file without having to guess where in a search path it came from today.

>
> Thomas proposed a "deprecated" mhttpd command line option.
>

"deprecated" does not work.

"we removed it because it stopped working and we cannot fix it" works,
"do not use it for new experiments" works (until a user comes back with "but I really like this feature!")
"we will remove it at an unknown future date because we think nobody should use it" does not work.

>
> As an alternative, I propose to make a symbolic link from <exptab>/resources to where the old /Custom/Path was pointing 
> to. This should work as well, and we don't have to implement a parameter in mhttpd.
> 

All experiments at TRIUMF that use old-style custom pages do not use /Custom/Path. In the new scheme
of things, setting /Custom/Path to anything other than blank will break them.

>
> Third, the /Custom/Path should really go away.
>

For once, I agree. /Custom/Path did not exist and should not have been added.

> We are all concerned that people can read security critical files from the whole file system.

Only in the default configuration and in configurations that would realistically used by an experiment. This
excludes the case of "/Custom/Path" set to "/etc" - not the default and unlikely to be used by any experiment.

> To read those files, people have to access to mhttpd, so they have to know at least the authentication credentials to pass the Apache firewall in front of mhttpd or 
> whatever. This means they have access to the ODB, and then they can simply change /Custom/Path to "/" and voila - they have again access to /etc/passwd.

Nope. They have to set /Custom/Path to "/etc" or start mhttpd under "/etc" or point /Custom/Path to a symlink to /etc. (mhttpd will not serve "etc/passwd", "/" in the filename is not permitted).

> This is why I propose symbolic links on the file system.

Some people dislike symlinks.
Some filesystems do not implement symlinks. (should we prevent mhttpd from running on the ms-dos fat filesystem "just because"?)

> This area is much better protected than the ODB, since people have to physically log into 
> a machine to change it.

Nope. You can create symlinks from mhttpd by putting running the "ln -s" command from ODB "/Programs/xxx/Start Command"

K.O.